Why doesn't the government introduce a procedure for refusing compulsory medical insurance for people who are not satisfied with public medicine?

Why doesn't the government introduce a procedure for refusing compulsory medical insurance for people who are not satisfied with public medicine?

Is it Safe to Return to the Workplace?

Previous questionWhat would a person's lifestyle, goals and values ​​be if the maximum life expectancy today was 25 years?
Next questionWhat is your favorite scent?

answers (4)

Answer 1
January, 2021

Compulsory medical insurance is not public medicine. A person may not be satisfied with state medicine and he may use compulsory medical insurance.

OMS is compulsory insurance, not state insurance. You can insure within these mandatory frameworks with anyone who provides such a service. And this CHI operator can send you to be treated not necessarily to a state clinic, but to the one with whom he concludes an agreement.

CHI and state clinics and hospitals are connected only by cheapness.

In theory , the reformers dreamed that people would not go to a bad state clinic and that it would not receive money from the CHI operators. Thus, financing will be regulated.

In practice, this does not happen for the simple reason that often people have nowhere else to go and they have too little money. This is an objective fact, the data on the poverty of the population are published by the government itself.

Why is it necessary to insure at all? This is a mechanism for the implementation of the constitutional right to health care and medical care. Anyone can break a leg. Get poisoned. To become a victim of a major accident, terrorist attack. And according to the law, he has the right to medical assistance. Calling an ambulance for you lying on the street with a heart attack will also be a passer-by not on a card in your wallet, but on a regular emergency phone number.

This is the general minimum level that compulsory health insurance should guarantee.

There are also infections that need to be fought massively, regardless of someone's desires. Tuberculosis, for example.

Answer 2
January, 2021

If you impose the payment of this tax on the citizens themselves, they will simply stop paying contributions. As a result, when they need medical care, they will not be eligible for free (they didn’t pay the fees), and the free one may not be affordable.

Answer 3
January, 2021

Because the right to minimum free health care is guaranteed by the constitution. And to realize this right, you need funds. And these funds are guaranteed, in turn, by obligatory deductions to the compulsory medical insurance.

Everything can be redone if desired, but one always pulls a bunch of another. And the question is, at whose expense will all this be organized?

In addition, the employer makes all contributions for an employee. In all other cases, no one makes any deductions. That is why our free medicine is so bad.

Answer 4
January, 2021

Because then it will be necessary to introduce differentiation in the accounting departments of the enterprises where these people work, since the employee will have to inform the employer whether it is necessary to pay contributions to the MHIF for him or not. You can, of course, transfer payments to the MHIF from employers to the employees themselves and force everyone to pay from their wallet in reality, and not virtually. Well then, maybe something will change, but I'm afraid the MHIF budget will collapse completely.

Related question

What is the safest way to undergo a course of medical fasting for a person with gastritis (do not offer sex and refuse fasting)?

Read more

A question for medical graduates: who were those classmates who bought / wrote with a micro-earphone (and not only) exams?

Read more

How did people satisfy the need for glucose, when sugar was not yet invented, and fruits and berries in the diet are few and they are seasonal?

Read more

Rights of Persons with Mental Illness under the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 of India (2020)

Is there a medical procedure like complete blood transfusion? (When all the patient's blood is replaced with donor blood) And if so, for what diseases?

Read more

If dietary supplements are not a medicine, then why do sick people, taking them, recover?

Read more

Why are the people afraid of overthrowing the government that has brought Russia and any sphere where you do not look to the African state?

Read more

Why do I have a sublime need for sex? I seem to be satisfied with my wife or with a porn video on day 2-3, but it's still not enough for me.

Read more

How are fingerprints taken (for example for a Schengen visa) from people who do not have hands?

Read more

EPA's Lead and Copper Proposal: Failing to Protect Public Health

Does the driver's medical commission in the Russian Federation really identify people who should not be allowed to drive a vehicle?

Read more

What are the motives of people who believe that HIV does not exist and that all this is a conspiracy of medicine and officials? After all, there are groups, sites, this is an organized movement

Read more

Are there any TheQ users who are disillusioned with atheism, rationalism, science, medicine, liberalism, or, for example, in the official version of any events?

Read more

Are the medical educated practitioners of alternative medicine doing it for money or out of a genuine belief in the effectiveness of “alternative” methods?

Read more

Why in Russian polyclinics usually they do not give a medical record to their hands and cannot be familiarized with it? What are the secrets from the patient?

Read more

Issues in the Economics of Medical Care | Timothy Terrell

Can a person with good self-esteem not want anything? Or does this apply exclusively to people who are insecure?

Read more

During the medical examination, the disease was revealed. The patient has been notified. Why do public sector doctors strongly insist on treatment with them, and not with private ones? Plan? Report?

Read more

Are people who kill even for a small profit and at the same time do not feel remorse after what they have done, are they sick?

Read more

Why is gluten harmful for the average person? If there are people around you who are gluten-intolerant?

Read more

Why do the priests say that diseases are given for great sins, but those who live on 5 people per sq m get sick, and those who are snickering in their castles do not hear anything about sores?

Read more

What Effect Does a DUI Charge Have On a License? #Lawyertalk #DUIGuy

The feeling that I am not in my body and not understanding why I am where I am, who all these people are nearby (even close ones). I have been scared for a long time. What to do?

Read more

What is needed for a technological race in the field of medicine to begin in the world, for example, but not an arms race, not a race to build up means of destroying people?

Read more