Why are the majority of doctors skeptical about traditional medicine?

Why are the majority of doctors skeptical about traditional medicine?

Herbs and Roots: A History of Chinese Doctors in the American Medical Marketplace

Previous questionIn case of an overdose, do you die with a high or are you already in agony?
Next questionWhy is there such a huge amount of sugar and fat in manufactured products?

answers (5)

Answer 1
April, 2021

It would be interesting to get acquainted with double-blind placebo-controlled studies of how the effects of taking 6-7 drugs are combined in a person, depending on his diet, level of physical activity, emotional state, and the amount of fluid taken. If there are any, you can just take off your hat.

In most cases, there is some assumption of reality, which may seem very solid to a patient without a worldview, although in fact it is a look at some fictional situation as "in a test tube", and not at a real person.

But without changing the paradigm of thinking, it is difficult for a doctor to go beyond this framework and psychologically it is more comfortable to believe that he is based on evidence, while traditional medicine is not. Otherwise, you can just go crazy with responsibility.

Wise doctors use their intuition and the results of their own experiments with might and main, passing it off as clinical thinking, which is actually the better, the more unusual cases are comprehended and the broader the views of the doctor's personality, not even necessarily related to medicine ... Rather, to how the world and man in general are arranged.

That's the whole tale about the truth of classical medicine and the lack of proof of traditional medicine. It is worth looking at the masterpieces of the era of the fight against coronavirus such as wearing masks by healthy people, walking around the house on a schedule and banning Turkish saunas and slides in water parks to prevent infection, as well as the "discovery" of the anti-inflammatory properties of dexamethasone and malaria drugs in covid19 therapy. This is us, in the 21st century gentlemen))) Bravo.

Coca-Cola, Becherovka, opium and bloodletting, prescribed by doctors of medicine with university degrees from the past centuries, can not even be remembered.

Answer 2
April, 2021

The basis of skepticism is ignorance ... The overwhelming majority of doctors, tortured by their daily work, have neither the time nor the desire to learn something new for them, work becomes a boring craft, and keen interest goes to other areas where you can disconnect from the gray work everyday life ... A real doctor, for whom medicine is an art, who lives by his work, is constantly looking for something new that will increase the effectiveness of treatment, as a rule, he studies and uses any methods and means of traditional medical systems of the world, for example, traditional Chinese medicine, Ayurveda, Tibetan medicine, etc.

Answer 3
April, 2021

Because doctors are afraid not of competition, but of the consequences of treatment by "grandmother's methods". Patients tend to first consult with the entire yard, then earn a complication, and then come to the doctor and accuse him that he cannot offer a miraculous deliverance in one day. Unfortunately, most of the unconventional methods are formulated in such a way that they look very attractive - inexpensive and simple. However, there is no free cheese in a mousetrap. The more serious the disease, the more reason to seek advice from a doctor.

Answer 4
April, 2021

Because at the medical university we were taught medical thinking. That is, the doctor, before prescribing anything, must have an idea of ​​how the disease flows and develops, as well as the mechanism of action of the drug. We prescribe a specific treatment not because "it is written so" or "it helped Baba Dusya from the sixth ward," but because we imagine exactly how and on what the given drug will work. Our knowledge is supported by evidence-based medicine, clinical trials.

Traditional medicine is based on unsubstantiated statements, placebo effect. If, for example, chamomile decoction helped "Baba Dusya", this does not mean that chamomile decoction helped her (there were no placebo-controlled studies on the use of chamomile decoction for this nosology). "After" does not mean "due to".

Answer 5
April, 2021

There are usually better alternatives to such treatments. There is no point in drinking decoctions of some herbs if there are already tablets that contain only the active ingredient and nothing more.

Related question

Why are so many people so skeptical about psychology as a science and psychotherapy as a method of treatment?

Read more

Integral medicine combines evidence-based and traditional medicine. Should you trust integrative medicine specialists?

Read more

What are some interesting films or TV series about doctors and medicine?

except for Dr. House.

Read more

Why Changing The Way You Breathe Will Transform Your Body and Mind with James Nestor

Have you ever been to foreign hospitals on vacation, tell us about your impressions of doctors and medicine in general?

Read more

Is the title of "PhD" in medicine a sign that he is a good doctor? Why are there so many of them now?

Read more

Why are some doctors so negligent about patient complaints?

And how are such people hired? After all, they took the Hippocratic oath.

Read more

Why do the overwhelming majority of doctors put stress on the letter I in the word "fluorography", if it is correct - on the letter A?

Read more

What is the best treatment for cough in children? Medicines or traditional methods?

Read more

How a Doctor Cured Her Autoimmune Disease with Functional Medicine

How to get rid of a runny nose when you do not have any medicines, there is no opportunity to purchase them, there is no means to create a medicine yourself (traditional medicine)?

Read more

What specialty do you get after graduating from the Faculty of Medicine and Biology? What are the "+" and "-" in front of the doctors?

Read more

Everyone knows about the plague doctors. Why didn't the image of medieval pharmacists gain such popularity?

Read more

Why do many doctors, knowing about the dangers of smoking, themselves have this habit?

Read more

Is there any way to determine that you have an unqualified doctor in front of you if you do not understand anything about medicine?

Read more

149: Dr. Erika Schwartz | Don’t Let Your Doctor Kill You

How do doctors treat coronavirus? Is it possible to avoid it? Why are civilians not being informed about the prevention and treatment of coronavirus?

Read more

Is there complete information about Plague Doctors? What did their premises look like, what did they use for treatment? What are the riddles about the doctors themselves?

Read more

Why is Russian medicine in such a deplorable state? What is being done to improve the situation of doctors and what awaits her in the future?

Read more

Why do they advertise a medicine? After all, doctors forbid self-administration.

Read more

Is it possible to dispute the professional suitability of a doctor if he advised to be treated with homeopathic medicines?

Read more

The Bloody Work of “Naturopathic Doctors” | Britt Hermes

How do doctors feel about the fact that relatives of patients are not allowed into the intensive care unit?

Read more

Why is it so important in medicine to declare a patient's "time of death" and why only a certain doctor can announce it?

Read more