Where did the theories about reincarnation come from, are there any logical explanations or arguments in favor of it?

Where did the theories about reincarnation come from, are there any logical explanations or arguments in favor of it?

The True Science of Parallel Universes

Previous questionHas anyone experienced hallucinations here? And then I wind myself up and I'm very afraid. Tell me what it is, so that I don't know how to be afraid of all the bullshit
Next questionHow to quickly recover from illness?

answers (2)

Answer 1
September, 2021

The theory of reincarnation first appeared in India, a very long time ago, apparently even before the emergence of writing.
But in European culture it became widespread thanks to hypnologists.
Somewhere in the middle of the 20th century, hypnosis was fashionable, and the age regression method was quite popular

wikipedia.org Some hypnologist decided to go further. "send" a person at a time when he was not yet born, and then everything started to turn. :) The hypnotized began to speak in languages ​​unknown to them before, name some dates and places, and even play musical instruments. True, such sessions at that time were sometimes, occasionally, held as a show ... but nevertheless, the idea went to the masses, incl. some research was carried out, similar to scientific research from afar.
And only after that all sorts of Indian practices began to come into vogue, along with which the Indian explanation of these phenomena came.

wikipedia.org

Answer 2
September, 2021

I'll throw in a couple of theses:

  1. The need to justify the world order. We want to believe that the world is just, reasonable, rational, that good is rewarded and evil is punished. And when we see that sometimes everything goes wrong, good people suffer, scoundrels thrive, and small children who have not yet done good or evil in their lives also suffer, get sick and die, this can destroy the picture of a just world. And then the concept of reincarnation comes to the rescue: reward or punishment in this life can overtake a person for the actions committed in the past.

  2. Mystical experience. Since ancient times, different people in different parts of the world have experienced unusual states of consciousness. This was facilitated by: the use of certain plants and mushrooms; rhythmic dances around the fire to the sound of a drum; less fuss and information noise, allowing some to lead a more contemplative lifestyle; head injuries while hunting; other practices, both spontaneous and quite intentional. Among these altered states of consciousness, there was obviously an out-of-body experience, that is, the experience of travel outside the physical body. Yes, and our distant ancestors probably treated ordinary dreams as a form of such an out-of-body experience. All this led a person to think about the soul as a substance capable of existing outside the body, separately and independently of it. And why not assume that after the death of one body, this soul migrates to another?

Related question

Why do many people believe that the immunodeficiency virus does not exist? Are there any strong arguments in favor of this theory?

Read more

Why is the menstrual cycle in women about 28 days? Where did this number come from?

Read more

Is the division of the brain hemispheres into those responsible for "creativity" and "logic" a myth? Where did this belief come from?

Read more

Donald Hoffman on Reality, Consciousness, and Conscious Agents | Closer To Truth Chats

Are there any scientific explanations for the state of déja vu?

Read more

Where did the myth about the incredible harm of ultrasound for the unborn child come from and how is it explained?

Read more

Where can I find confirmation of the theory that during sexual intercourse, a man gives up his energy, and a woman receives it (+/-), or did I come up with it myself? :)

Read more

Where did the 90-60-90 standard come from?

Read more

And where did the tradition of calling "night butterflies" come from in baths and saunas, that now it is even included in the services of these establishments?

Read more

The Three Jokers Identities: The Three Jokers Part 2 | Comics Explained

Why are there different images of monsters in our minds and in dreams, and we are afraid of them, even if we do not take into account horror films, where did this come from?

Read more

Where did the child's organs (heart, brain, etc.) come from in the mother's belly - out of nowhere?

Read more

Where did the word "cancer" come from, as the name of the disease?

Read more

Where did the Ebola virus come from and why is it so dangerous?

Read more

Where did the fashion for a nose ring come from? Why is it so popular now?

Read more

The Egg - A Short Story

Where did the fashion for selfharm come from?

Read more

Where did the phrase "Curled up in three deaths" come from?

Read more

Are there sites / applications where you can solve logic problems with the search for patterns of numbers, differences, etc.?

Read more

Is the theory about the materialization of thought true or is it just another trend in popular psychology?

Read more

Where do voices come from outside in the head of the mentally ill? What is their physiology? Why are they almost always negative or related to harm?

Read more

Is Reality Real? The Simulation Argument

Where does the pulling pain in the bends of the elbows and knees come from? What hurts there?

Read more

Is it true that female alcoholism is not cured, and where did this phrase come from?

Read more