The manufacturer makes a technical liquid based on ethanol, and then changes the ethanol in its composition to methanol. Is he to blame for the fact that someone poisoned her?

The manufacturer makes a technical liquid based on ethanol, and then changes the ethanol in its composition to methanol. Is he to blame for the fact that someone poisoned her?

Safety during Distillation

Previous questionIs caffeine actually contributing to cellulite, or is it just a myth?
Next questionWhy is the presence of temperature checked by touching the forehead?

answers (4)

Answer 1
January, 2021

On the one hand, those who drank are to blame for drinking what should not be drunk.

On the other hand, the use of methanol in cosmetics is prohibited, the methyl alcohol content was not indicated on the label ... Therefore, the manufacturer is also to blame, but for a different reason. For this and judge. Even if someone used these products as directed, methanol is dangerous, including in contact with the skin, and not only when ingested

Answer 2
January, 2021

This is a game. Both sides are involved. Some pretend that they release something that is not intended for ingestion, others drink it.

Many do not understand the essence of the problem for the state. It is not about blaming someone for the harm done. Yes, sellers and manufacturers will have problems. But precisely because they violated the rules for the circulation of methanol. In Russia, the use of methanol in consumer products is prohibited.

If this ban seems unfair, then this issue must be resolved at the level of legislation. Yes, this requires politics, courts, elections and all that stuff. And just take and break the law out of quiet sadness pouring methanol because he decided something himself, no need.

Yes, the right way is to change the culture of alcohol consumption. There should be cheap beer and wine for those who wish.

It is impossible to completely eliminate the consumption of any surrogates. But the state cannot simply ignore this problem. And the reason is very simple.

According to the law, according to the constitution, we all, each of us, have the right to medical assistance.

The problem is that no one is able to distinguish the order of methanol poisoning from poisoning with completely ordinary alcohol purchased is completely legal in the most honest expensive beautiful store.

Moreover, usually no one distinguishes a person who has a bad heart from an alcoholic. For simplicity, they pretend that they have not noticed anything and walk past.

Medicine is obliged to rush equally to a person who jumped out of the window on its own and to a person thrown out of the window. These people do not look different.

Medical care is very expensive.

That is why it is easier for the state to ban methyl alcohol than to spend huge sums of money to eliminate the consequences of its use.

I am very critical of the ban. But, for a second, what and who limits the control over the turnover of methanol? Ethyl alcohol is no worse, it will perfectly replace. And it's just as cheap. Was it made artificially expensive? Well, this problem must be solved.

To avoid drinking ethyl alcohol, we need a culture of alcohol consumption.

Only we have a crisis. Is always. Hence the problems. You know, besides work, living environment, there is also such an elementary story. Where it is not customary to consume alcohol, for example, sweets are popular. Here, recently, I wanted to buy a cake on the DR. After 21 hours. Branded pastry shops are closed (they are still not at every step). And in hypermarkets one tops, which are a little tired. There is nothing within walking distance. Found one boutique pastry shop. It contains cake in pieces - three times more expensive than in a branded confectionery. You have to drink for this.

P.S. Yes, more. People with disabilities will now undergo rehabilitation and receive a pension. There is also blindness, even with a moderate degree of poisoning. We represent, yes, a new burden on the state thanks to some cunning businessmen who broke the law. Giving a disability pension based on guilt is not possible. If they shared where, as I understand it, they did not give to anyone, then they gave war invalids who distinguished themselves in the service, then all war invalids, then all invalids in general.

And another observation. There are also a lot of comments on my local forum - they are to blame, hurray, self-sawing, etc. But I just remembered that on the same forum, draft alcohol was excellently sold.

Answer 3
January, 2021

Substitution of one ingredient for another is illegal. So yes, it's my fault. After all, he did not write after the replacement that the ethanol in the composition was replaced by methanol. Those. misled the consumer.

Answer 4
January, 2021

With product quality, yes. you need to understand.
But I don't really understand, what are the claims to the manufacturers about the poisoning?
On the bubbles it is clearly written that the products are NOT INTENDED FOR INSIDE CONSUMPTION.
When I was little, we also had drunken animals lying in the bushes with bottles of "snowflake" windshield wipers. But it never occurred to anyone to declare them guilty.

If we are looking for such, I suggest paying attention to the state. Who, except the state and officials, can be to blame for the sharp drop in living standards and, as a consequence, the increase in the number of citizens who live below the poverty line and are unable to buy high-quality alcoholic beverages? Obviously, nobody.
And after all, every day all over Russia someone dies because of the consumption of low-quality alcohol. And they remembered only now.

Apparently, we need a scapegoat. Therefore, the creators of the damn lotion are accused of poisoning people. Lotion not intended for oral consumption, let me remind you.

Related question

Can a person not feel anything despite the fact that he has never felt love on himself? Only hate and anger from people? Is there someone like that?

Read more

If there is an all-loving God, then why is there unbearable physical pain? And if someone commits suicide because of her, he must go to hellish torture?

Read more

Is it normal that I love a person for loving me? And for the fact that he loves me, I want to repay even more, love even more?

Read more

How to make Alcohol at Home (Ethanol)

If all the products were written exactly what they are, for example: a piece of the body of a slaughtered pig, a poison based on ethyl alcohol with a taste of grapes, then? ..?

Read more

Is it true that if you have anal sex with a girl and then put pressure on her belly, then she will crap?

Read more

Is it possible to draw a conclusion about the level of human intelligence based on the music he listens to?

Read more

Is it true that ferns cause cancer and, despite the fact that they are considered food plants, their use is dangerous, if not for life, then for health?

Read more

What does the fact that he tortured and killed animals in childhood says about a person?

Read more

How Science Got Us to 2020 | Compilation

How to deal with the fact that often when the weather changes, your head hurts and it is very difficult to concentrate on work?

Read more

How to make it clear to a friend that he has all the symptoms of HIV infection if he is a nervous and sensitive person?

Read more

If drugs are illegal, then why, when in an interview or in a song, someone says that they have taken them, they are not imprisoned for it?

Read more

How does Keanu Reeves look so young despite the fact that he has had a very difficult life and the fact that he does not try to look after himself?

Read more

Is it true that if you squint your eyes and then someone hits you on the back of the head, they will remain so forever?

Read more

How to make herbal extracts

Is it possible, based on the analysis of the content of VK publics, to conclude that the state of the girl's backside takes priority over the content of her inner world?

Read more

How substantiated are the statements about the genetic degeneration of mankind due to the fact that medicine bears everyone in a row, and then these people pass on defective genes?

Read more

Is it useful to eat Nutrilon baby food with a unique composition for the development of immunity and intelligence in adults?

Read more

Is it true that in the Middle Ages, people saw massive religious hallucinations due to ergot poisoning?

Read more

A friend is thinking about suicide due to the fact that she is in a difficult relationship with her young man, she is 35 and recently she cut his veins with him in revenge.?

Read more

Dr. Doron Sher - 'Artificial Sweeteners'

Is it difficult for a girl to physically drive a car, turn the steering wheel, estimate dimensions, press the pedals, cope with a manual transmission based on physiology?

Read more

How to make a visit to the vet the least traumatic (psychologically) for a cat? He is terribly afraid, and he is sick already on the doorstep to the clinic.

Read more