If an artificial mind is created, will this be proof of the fallacy of religious ideas about the immaterial soul and the afterlife?

If an artificial mind is created, will this be proof of the fallacy of religious ideas about the immaterial soul and the afterlife?

PHILOSOPHY - David Hume

Previous questionCan robots replace humans in medicine?
Next questionHow to care for a man's nails?

answers (7)

Answer 1
September, 2021

When a self-improving artificial intelligence is created, it will be something closest to what we now call God. It is difficult to say how much this God will be similar to what is described in the historical religious books, and where everything will be like a living being, this is the singularity ... we'll see soon.

Answer 2
September, 2021

Soul and mind are different things.

Souls are created for spiritual growth, which is mainly designed to acquire it (growth) through life choices (actions) based on feelings, and not on reason.

Even if an artificial mind is created, scientists will definitely not be able to endow it with feelings.

Therefore, the answer to the question is NO! This will not be proof of the error of religious beliefs about the soul.

Answer 3
September, 2021

If you mean a computer-based artificial intelligence, then creating it will confirm that:

  1. Intelligence in the form of software and data can be transferred to other hardware. If we put the old iron in a coffin, then we have an afterlife.

  2. Reason in the form of software and data may not depend on the material medium. That is, in a sense, the mind is not very attached to matter.

Religion in general from an evolutionary point of view is very rational, you just need to realize that evolution has gone from the genetic to the cultural level, and religion is a replacement for overcome instincts and the basis of culture.

Accordingly, the soul is human culture (and it is slightly immaterial). The afterlife is children, students and followers.

Answer 4
September, 2021

I'll make a reservation right away that the following is, as they say, IMHO. I do not pretend to be the ultimate truth :)

Artificial intelligence, even if it is created, will think in completely different categories than we do. Our perception of the world is based on biological instincts: self-preservation, reproduction. And our whole psyche is, roughly speaking, a superstructure over them. Religion, God is a natural need of our psyche.

This is not typical for a machine. Moreover, for her it will mean absolutely nothing. I doubt that a sufficiently intelligent mechanism will be anything like us.

In other words, the question of whether there is a God, for a machine simply will not make sense.

Answer 5
September, 2021

There is a statement by the Dalai Lama on the topic of an artificial body and posthumous existence. He was asked whether artificial intelligence similar to human could exist, he replied that if scientists create such a shell that will meet the conditions for the embodiment of the mind in it, then such an existence will become possible. In other words, the robot in which the mind is embodied will need to be treated in the same way as other living beings. It will not be possible to kill him, lie to him, etc.

Answer 6
September, 2021

Of course not. Purely logically, without a decision about how it really is, the existence of something artificial does not refute other forms of existence of this phenomenon.

The creation of an artificial mind - it has actually been created, albeit not very complicated, but it is already a technical question. Moreover, the fact that this was possible was understood for a very long time. Systems that change their state depending on the external environment and give solutions are generally purely mechanical.

Sort items by size. It is not difficult to come up with a mechanism for this - a gutter with holes of different sizes. This is already the most primitive reason. The computer differs from such schemes not qualitatively, but quantitatively.

But to the artificial intelligence, which has self-awareness, approaches are not yet visible. The fact that this is only a very complex reason is so far postulated on the basis that it is impossible to imagine otherwise.

But even if an artificial consciousness is created, there are no fundamental religious problems here. Of course, people will be treated differently.

In Abrahamic religions, only God is immortal and immaterial, all others, including souls, are at least partially material and immortal only by virtue of their support from God. It is not strictly dogmatically decided what state the soul is in after death until the general resurrection. Why not assume, for example, that God preserves the configuration of matter that defines the soul, how do we save a computer session in "hypersleep" mode until the next turn on?

By the way, I wonder if artificial consciousness will create its own religion or join existing? )

Answer 7
September, 2021

I'm not entirely sure that mind and soul are the same thing. Moreover, during our lifetime this will definitely not happen - how the brain works is known only in the sense of mechanisms, but there are so many nerve cells that it is impossible to do this. We have a big brain, and there are all sorts of insects, snakes - that even their nervous system cannot be imitated.

If it works out, and if it turns out, in fact, that the mind and the soul are one and the same (from the point of view of theology), it proves nothing. When God expels Adam and Eve from his Garden, he says: "Now you are one of us" (after the apple). This phrase can easily be used to explain that a person can also create a soul (or God through a person). And we can say that the Lord specifically allowed this to test the strength of your faith. In general, a person is not able to prove the absence or presence of the Almighty and Almighty. Believers can also say that atheists simply believe that there is no God.

As they joked: Can the Almighty and Almighty God create a stone that he himself cannot lift. "

Related question

If damage to individual parts of the brain leads to personality deformation, then why do many still consider the soul to be immaterial and indivisible?

Read more

If we can fully understand the work of the brain, then will it help create an artificial copy, AI?

Read more

Could it be that mankind will create an artificial intelligence unnoticed for itself and will discover it many years later?

Read more

THE EMPEROR OF MAN [3] The Imperial Lie - WARHAMMER 40,000 Lore / History

In your opinion, is it possible in the future to create artificial bodies? And how much is it really possible to transfer the personality, consciousness and soul of a person into this very body?

Read more

What creates an impulse in the brain that gives a train of thought / idea / desire?

Read more

Will an injection of a sedative reduce blood loss? The idea is that it will lower your heart rate and reduce the flow of blood from the wound?

Read more

Which is better: your own website or public? There is an idea to blog about psychiatry, but there were difficulties with choosing a platform, and there is not enough experience. I will not refuse help, co-authorship is being considered)?

Read more

Why does the soul hurt if it is not an organ and has no nerve endings?

Read more

Does Consciousness Defeat Materialism? | Episode 1609 | Closer To Truth

Can I eat human feces? That is, to create such an endless chain of devouring your feces? And will the feces eaten be digested?

Read more

What are the difficulties of creating artificial blood?

Read more

Where to go on a journey in order to know the facets of the soul, learn more about spiritual practices and just be alone with your thoughts?

Read more

Is it true that a person's weight decreases at the time of death? Can this be considered evidence of the existence of the soul?

Read more

If the diet consists only of proteins (no fats and carbohydrates) and they managed to create a calorie surplus, will body fat be burned?

Read more

Stephen Greenblatt on Lucretius and his intolerable ideas

Have you ever realized in a dream that you are sleeping? And, what do you think, does this speak about any peculiarities of the character / mind / etc.?

Read more

Do you have a soul? And the other person? What about animals? Okay, what about the Neanderthal? And what about the amoeba, virus, dna? A calculator?

Read more

Is the mind an inborn or acquired feature of a person?

Read more

What about appearance if guys do not like small breasts (size 2 is not small) and artificial ones too?

Read more

Will a self-learning artificial intelligence be able to value its unique experience and experience the fear of death because of it?

Read more

TEDx Brussels 2010 - Stuart Hameroff - Do we have a quantum Soul?

Why live? You will be the smartest, make a huge contribution, create a system. Just for this?

Read more

How do you tell a teacher that you will not write an essay on a given topic for (religious, moral) reasons and stay right?

Read more