I want to catch up with all the school classics. Can I watch films based on works, or is it better to read books?

I want to catch up with all the school classics. Can I watch films based on works, or is it better to read books?

The Stories of Art, Freedom, and Poetry | Bob Chitester, Documentarian

Previous questionWhat causes irritation in the form of acne on the chest and back? How to deal with this? Boy, 16 years old
Next questionHow to get rid of the feeling of being used?

Answers (7)

Answer 1
November, 2020

If you watch films based on classical works, then it is better to focus on those that were shot by Soviet cinema, since at that time the best human qualities reflected by classic authors in their works were highly valued. Today this theme in cinema is so blurred, and sometimes even replaced by not the best examples, that the main idea of ​​the work is lost or washed out, to the greatest regret.
Reading is certainly better. You can agree with the author in some way, you can disagree. Through reading, the personality of the author is better visible, images appear in thoughts - their own, and therefore they are more lively and understandable.
Reading classics is not always easy, but always useful!

Answer 2
November, 2020

A good program in Russian and Soviet literature was, of course, immense and, frankly, overwhelming. A big role should have been played by language teachers ... But, alas ... If there is a desire to start mastering Russian and Soviet classics on your own, then ten or twelve works are enough ... A word about Igor's regiment; Woe from Mind; Belkin's stories; Hero of our time; Auditor; Crime and Punishment; War and Peace; Old Isergil; Twelve; A cloud in pants; Mother's letter; Quiet Don. And also watch their film adaptations. And most importantly - get a good general notebook, where you write notes about what you read and what you saw ... Good luck ...

Answer 3
November, 2020

Watching movies and reading the original are two different activities. The point is not to quickly learn the plot, but to read, reflect on the work, or on the movie you watched. A screen adaptation is a director's view of a given work, which may differ from your perception. So read and watch. Literature and cinema are two types of art.

Answer 4
November, 2020

Read books, definitely.

But if you don't know how to read (sorry, I didn't mean "you don't know how to read." Only literary scholars can really read, and even then not all) ... it's just scary to tackle a great work, you can prepare your own perception by watching a good film adaptation.

For example, "War and Peace" by Bondarchuk. There are several adaptations, but all of them are not about this, not about Russia, although some are quite good. But ... one day I decided to watch the latest "imported" film adaptation, a series that I carefully rewrote. I turned on the computer, and got to our home (I have all the classics for daddies). It was a scene when Prince Andrei, who was leaving for the war, said goodbye to his father (Andrei - Tikhonov, old prince - Ktorov). And I have already prepared for the new English version. I just missed - compared to ours, the British seemed, let the sweetest and smartest of dogs forgive me, mongrels. Yes . The British tried hard and played well, but they had no idea what a Russian person is ... So start with Bondarchuk.

I highly recommend Schweitzer's Little Tragedies. There is such Vysotsky (his last film role), Such Jurassic, such Smoktunovsky and all the others.

Wonderful "Snowstorm" by Basova.

Charming "Lady-peasant"

Answer 5
November, 2020

Books, of course, are the best :-) But if it's difficult, then you can watch movies. There are good adaptations of Pushkin, Lermontov, Goncharov, Tolstoy and Dostoevsky.

Answer 6
November, 2020

Sometimes there will be better screen versions of books. I can definitely say this about the Russian TV series "The Idiot" and "Crime and Punishment". The works of Dostoevsky were perfectly filmed. And the actors very well conveyed the whole atmosphere of the book. I recommend watching.

Answer 7
November, 2020

To be honest, at one time I read a significant part of the school curriculum "in abbreviated form", on any sites where the plot is transmitted over several pages. To understand the essence of what was happening, this was enough, and we were not asked more in the classroom. Some of it made up at the university, some books after graduation, I have not yet reached some classical works.

So it all depends on why you need to make up for the school curriculum at all. Are you still studying and want to get to know the plots quickly? To be honest, most of the films based on books did not go to me, and some film adaptations distort the plot. It is impossible to study the works or biography of Gogol on the film-series of the same name, for example.

Some films take longer to watch than to read the works on which they are based, so saving time is also not always possible. For example, "Scarlet Sails" is easier to read than watching "Assol" from 1982. The same applies to performances based on Chekhov's stories (they were shown to us in class at school, and IMHO, it is easier, more interesting and faster to read stories, may the lovers of Soviet cinema forgive me).

If you want to tighten up the missed knowledge, then it is better to watch from the timing and your interest. Of course, books are always preferable - after all, the primary source. But if reading is hard and there is no time at all, and there is no time to educate yourself, the films will do quite well, and it is possible that some will inspire you to read books. Of those I personally liked, I would advise "Cruel Romance" (based on Ostrovsky's "Dowry") - again, in the lesson we watched the film adaptation, and this inspired me and many classmates to get acquainted with the original. Bulgakov's "Heart of a Dog" - well, this is already a classic, and I saw her at the age of 10, long before they began to study at school. "Quiet Don" and "The Brothers Karamazov" - if you do not have a reverent attitude in the spirit of "cinema is a castrated version of literature!", Better look, Soviet film adaptations are good and give a complete picture of the plot, and time is saved. In the end, if some story hooks, you can always read the original - the classic is not afraid of spoilers)

Related question

Why don't I remember the content of books and films that I read and watched earlier?

Read more

I like to read, but as soon as I read, I immediately fall asleep, even if the book is interesting, how to overcome it? (With films the same)

Read more

Which is better for sight: reading from an iPad display, reading a regular paper book, or reading with a reader?

Read more

253: Permeated & Vitalized by Spiritual Sound

Share, at the medical institute the program starts from scratch, or should I already be with a good school base?

Read more

How to quickly repeat the school curriculum in all subjects? What sites or books are there where the entire school curriculum is narrowed?

Read more

Recommend a book on sports and nutrition. So that you can come up with a workout for yourself. I don't want to rape myself, exhaust me.?

Read more

How can you characterize a person who loves to re-read books you like, watch films and TV series, sometimes even twice in a row?

Read more

What film would you say: “I want to erase my memory in order to watch it again”?

Read more

Chase Terrace Academy Open Evening 2020

I want to read, but I lack perseverance. The books are interesting, the conditions at home are created; but no patience, constantly distracted? What is it?

Read more

What books can you read to understand how the human body works?

Read more

Is it better to wake up naturally or with an alarm?

Read more

Why can someone read all night and not fall asleep, while someone already yawns after a couple of pages and on the tenth is asleep over a book? How to deal with sleep while reading?

Read more

Which is better: self-medication based on information on the Internet, or treatment by current doctors in small towns?

Read more

The Very Hungry Caterpillar - Animated Film

What are the best books to read about drugs to better understand their effects on the body?

Read more

The shoulder joint hurts from push-ups on one arm, not the muscles. Is this a joke that I don't understand, or is it better to stop doing push-ups on it for now?

Read more

I want to find out all my health problems, to be examined on all counts, something like a medical examination at school. Where and how it can be done

Read more

Previously, I could read for hours, but now I get tired after a few minutes, even if the book is interesting. With what it can be connected?

Read more

I want to eat sweets all the time. What is it and is it worth fighting with?

Read more

5 Ways to Read Faster That ACTUALLY Work - College Info Geek

I want to swim in salt water without glasses. I'm scared of fine sand and other small garbage that can scratch the eye? Is it dangerous to swim like this or is it better with glasses?

Read more

I realized that I was starting to get stupid and I could not concentrate on reading the book. I started reading Freud's "Introduction to Psychoanalysis" for a general outlook, but I don't read it for a long time?

Read more