How do doctors, and especially Jewish doctors, relate to circumcision ("giyuru")? Why is he?

How do doctors, and especially Jewish doctors, relate to circumcision ("giyuru")? Why is he?

Previous questionIs it true that there is LGBT propaganda and that it can help you become gay? What are the criteria for such propaganda?
Next questionWhat is this weird sleep paralysis feeling when falling asleep?

answers (4)

Answer 1
January, 2021

As a psychologist, I will say that this is a serious trauma.

And note one regularity that where circumcision occurs, there is a woman in a completely dependent position and there is a problem of sexual harassment. I am Jewish and am against it.

Answer 2
January, 2021

As mentioned above, it is necessary to separate two concepts: conversion - conversion to Judaism, and brit mila - ritual circumcision in Judaism, which boys in traditional Jewish families undergo on the 8th day of life.

Answer 3
January, 2021

Not really. Giyur is a transition to Jewry (or to Judaism, but only in Russian are these concepts divorced). Eniwei, a person becomes a Jew. And for anyone who is a Jew by birth (the son of a Jewish mother) or a Jew by such a conscious step, there is a procedure for "initiation" of himself as a Jew. So it is impossible to pass conversion without it. If translated into a metaphor (voiced in the link below by Mikhail Stavropolsky): there is a certain agreement with Gd, everything suits him from our side, us from him, all the documentation has been prepared, it remains to make a signature. That is, to perform the rite of brit-mila (circumcision). It was I who answered the question "Why is circumcision necessary?" from the point of view of the Jewish tradition. The procedure is performed by a specially trained rabbi, and for this he does not need to have a complete medical education.

On the other hand, this procedure is carried out for medical reasons, for example, for phimosis. It is performed by a surgeon, and by Jewish surgeons, including if the Jew is a urological surgeon. It is logical, right?)

As a future doctor (and a Jew, for that matter), I have a positive attitude to the procedure of ritual circumcision, at least because it makes the future life of a man easier. Here the gentlemen share their impressions: thequestion.ru

Some time ago, by the way, in the United States there was a fashion for circumcision among secular men of various nationalities - they did it purely for pragmatic reasons of hygiene. Indeed, this is an excellent prevention of infections, since the likelihood of the development of a nutrient medium for microorganisms under the foreskin decreases, and therefore, the risk of the growth of populations of pathogenic bacteria among them decreases. And it's not about being lazy to take a shower.

Answer 4
January, 2021

Conversion and circumcision are not exactly the same thing. You can perform conversion, but do without circumcision.

Circumcision, in general, is a useful thing, if you do not bring in some kind of infection. Under the foreskin, active substances are secreted, which can even cause oncology. They must either be washed off regularly and thoroughly, preferably with soap. Or cut off the foreskin, then these substances will rub off on the clothes. Of course, this is not the equivalent of washing with soap, and the clothes will emit a smell after that, but it is still better than nothing.

If you consider yourself a clean person and wash regularly, then you may not bother with any what circumcisions. And if you are ready to stain your clothes with odorous secretions, just not to wash, then you cannot do without circumcision.

Related question

Why is circumcision worth / not worth doing?

Read more

What do you think opinion, the main differences between medicine and biology? Especially in related areas.?

Read more

Why does a fly like to crawl over a person, especially when he is sleeping?

Read more

Why is it not customary for doctors to treat their relatives?

Read more

How do Jews and Muslims view circumcision?

Read more

How is euthanasia interpreted from a religious point of view - in relation to the doctor who performs it, and in relation to the patient?

Read more

Tears serve to moisturize the eyes and remove foreign bodies. But why does a person cry when he is sad? How is this related?

Read more

How is circumcision done?

Read more

Why is it widespread in the United States to circumcise babies? And what is it for?

Read more

Why do relatives have privileges to visit sick people and how can a loved one who is not relatives get to a sick person?

Read more

Hello, please tell me why is he and for what reason the doctor prescribes?

Read more

Do you also have a tongue with a white coating, especially closer to the root? How to live with this if no doctor can find anything problematic?

Read more

How do doctors feel about the fact that relatives of patients are not allowed into the intensive care unit?

Read more

If a person resembles his specific relative, does this mean that he will inherit his sores and how much he will be genetically similar to him?

Read more

What to a doctor when a patient dies because of him? What is happening to him and what is he doing?

Read more

How do you know if a person has actually lost memory or is he just pretending? How do doctors recognize such simulators?

Read more

Why is a doctor called a neuropathologist and not a neuropathologist, because he deals with nerves, not neurons?

Read more

How do doctors relate to the human body of patients, including the genitals and internal organs, as well as the peculiarities of the psyche? Does this interfere with doctors' daily life?

Read more

Delusional disorder with a friend. He does not want to be treated, does not trust anyone, becomes dangerous for others and himself. Relatives cannot help. What to do?

Read more

Eyesight has dropped dramatically lately. And he continues. What to do? The doctor said to take pills and wear lenses. Gymnastics doesn't really help.

Read more