Can you define yourself or another person as uniquely smart or stupid?

Can you define yourself or another person as uniquely smart or stupid?

36 Smart and Interesting Responses to 'HOW ARE YOU?'

Previous questionWhat if my parents came up to me and told me that I was adopted?
Next questionIs it worth going to work 14 hours a day 2/2 if they pay well there, but you are 18 years old?

answers (4)

Answer 1
January, 2021

You can, if you want. This definition will not affect anything in real life, except for your self-esteem or the perception of others, if you are going to define out loud.

For me, there are no "smart" or "stupid" people. Not even "relatively smart (or stupid)". There are qualities of intelligence that can be tested (and even then not absolutely) - speed of thinking, memory, ability to analyze, to abstract thinking, technical / humanitarian tendency to think, etc. There is erudition - that is, the amount of human knowledge at the moment. There is creativity - that is, the ability to come up with something new based on existing experience. There are beliefs that may be “right” in the eyes of some people and “wrong” in the eyes of others. But what is "mind" and "stupidity" - no one can say clearly. Because these are just concepts that we ourselves came up with.

Answer 2
January, 2021

In my opinion, the relative scale is more practical. Based on the study of the corresponding words in the Russian language, it can be roughly estimated that the concept of mind in Russian speakers includes such components as 'skill / professionalism', 'knowledge / erudition', 'common sense / wisdom', 'dexterity / ingenuity'. There are people who are smarter than you, there are people who are dumber than you. This means that there are people who understand this matter better than you, there are people who understand this matter worse than you. There are people who have more knowledge than you, and people who have less than yours. There are people who see farther than you, and people who do not see as far as you. There are people who think faster and people who think slower than you. It remains to determine what is more important for you at the moment in the interlocutor, and evaluate whether you are higher or lower by this criterion. Common sense dictates that it is always better to slightly overestimate the capabilities of the interlocutor, such an error in the assessment is easier to correct than the opposite :)

Answer 3
January, 2021

You can. To do this, you need to choose some testable criterion for assessing the mind / stupidity. For example, the result of an IQ test or the speed of verbal counting or the number of books read or the number of followers on Facebook, etc.

The hardest part is to believe that this scale really reflects the level of intelligence :)

Answer 4
January, 2021

I am definitely a smart person. And defining myself this way, I feel doubts and vulnerability of this definition, and my helplessness in front of those who want to redefine "me" for themselves. I have no power to deprive others of the ability to think "Only a really stupid person can so categorically declare his mind. After all, a smart one knows only that he knows nothing."

And the point is in philosophy. Determination is a volitional act that can be judged by different people from different points of view as smart or stupid. From the point of view of Aristotelian logic, there is an obvious conflict here: someone MUST BE right, and someone else is wrong. You have to choose.

To reduce the intensity of this conflict, I can narrow the scope and definitions by saying: “At this moment, in my own eyes, I am an unambiguously intelligent person. Who admits that there are three other person, one of whom uses his will to join my definition, the other, by a volitional effort for himself, crosses out my definition and appoints me a pseudo-smart nerd, and the third who saw in this text both sound thoughts and stupidity in my unambiguity or what something else. "

The question remains ... why did I define myself like this? I'll leave the answer to myself and invite readers to think about why they define themselves in one way or another?

Related question

How can you become as smart as Sherlock from the TV series Elementary?

Read more

By what criteria do you assess whether a person is smart or not?

Read more

Memes are only for the silly ones, or can a smart person also learn something from them?

Read more

I've lived as a man & a woman -- here's what I learned | Paula Stone Williams | TEDxMileHigh

What sites, resources and online magazines do you know that are as informative and unique as TheQuestion?

Read more

What kind of person can be called smart?

Read more

If a person reads books by authors such as Olga Buzova or Nikolai Sobolev, does this mean that he is stupid?

Read more

Can a person with a sense of humor be stupid?

Read more

What if someone calls Vladimir Putin in my presence as an evil, rude, stupid and uncivilized person? Where to call ?

Read more

Describe Your Character and Personality in English

Can a person with good academic performance be not very smart?

Read more

What questions should you ask yourself? Which ones do you personally ask yourself?

Read more

Do you think it is possible to determine by facial expressions that a person is stupid?

Read more

How can you set a person on fire so as not to cause him discomfort?

Read more

I pee with laughter as long as I can remember, I can’t restrain myself. what to do? is it worth going to a gynecologist or is it a question from another specialist?

Read more

Why incompetent people think they're amazing - David Dunning

How can you define your type of character? Give a definition to each of them, if possible.

Read more

If a person cannot look into the eyes of another person (specific; in principle, people can), what does this mean?

Read more

Why does vomiting occur after seeing the dismembered bloody bodies of a person or murder, and not another reaction?

Read more

Is there any real benefit from the daily use of mineral water (such as Borjomi or Novoterskaya), or are these just another folk recipe?

Read more

Why is Zika virus dangerous? Can he come to Russia or is this just another myth?

Read more

Are You Smarter Than Average?

When I die, I will cease to be aware of myself, because the brain will die and "I" along with it. But can I be born and feel myself in the body of another person, as now?

Read more

I notice some minor psychological problems. Is it worth contacting a psychologist or can you figure it out yourself?

Read more