Are preventive surgeries like the ones Angelina Jolie underwent justified?

Are preventive surgeries like the ones Angelina Jolie underwent justified?

Exclusive: Thousands of women put at risk of cancer

Previous questionWhy did doctors do or are doing electroconvulsive and electroshock therapy?
Next questionWho is a Geriatrician?

answers (4)

Answer 1
January, 2021

Of course, everyone can do whatever they want with themselves. But it seems strange to me to advertise the removal of this or that organ, especially for a public person - they look at you, they look up to you, they imitate you. Unreasonable operations will begin in people who are not threatened by this problem. And if the breast can be removed without visible consequences for the body - not a vital organ, but if there is a risk of colon or brain cancer? Do you want to remove them too?

Answer 2
January, 2021

If I had been identified at risk BEFORE cancer was diagnosed, I would also gladly cut off all suspicious body parts in advance so as not to be afraid. It is a pity that nothing boded. But I will probably remove the breasts as soon as possible.

Because it is very difficult - cancer. And it's scary after cancer.

Answer 3
January, 2021

Angelina Jolie was tested for a gene mutation, the risk of developing the disease was assessed taking into account her pedigree. I think she did examinations for a number of other indicators. Most likely, the actress decided on a mastectomy not only on the basis of a genetic test - of course, an integrated approach is important here. A few years later, Jolie underwent surgery to remove the ovaries. This step is understandable, because women in natural menopause are at increased risk of ovarian cancer. For her, it was a justified preventive measure, given the BRCA1 gene mutation. But at the same time, any woman with a similar mutation should not immediately run and remove her reproductive organs, since each case is individual, and the risks consist not only of genetic predispositions, but also of biochemical changes, tumor markers and other indicators.

The BRCA1 gene is generally very large, and there may now be more than 1,500 mutations in it. To figure out which mutation is found in a person and how it will affect the development of the disease, you need to do a lot of work, look at all scientific articles on the topic - a geneticist is engaged in this.

If it is proved that a certain mutation increases the risk of occurrence cancer up to 87% (with Jolie this is an indicative clinical case), then you need to make operational decisions

Answer 4
January, 2021

They are justified, at least, by a comfortable mental state.

It has a great effect on the brain when you know that both your grandmother and mother died of cancer and when you see that all their chronic ailments are like this and you, even without knowing about the genes, you can experience it acutely. Taking into account also psychosomatic phenomena ...

Related question

In 2013, he underwent surgery: plastic nasal septum. After that, crusts constantly form in one nostril. What to do?

In 2013, he underwent surgery: plastic surgery of the nasal septum, concholateropexy of the inferior turbinates, resection of the posterior ends of the inferior turbinates. After that, in one (exactly one!) Nostril, increased mucus production, drying and the appearance of crusts began (or the pr...

Read more

How Dangerous is Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery? After the fracture of the jaw, they underwent recovery, they offer an additional operation. Agree?

Read more

How can appendicitis be prevented and, if it occurs, do without surgery?

Read more

Actress Angelina Jolie Reveals She Had Preventative Surgery To Remove Ovaries, Fallopian Tubes

Can I have surgery to purr like a cat?

Read more

He underwent medical examination at the military registration and enlistment office. After a while, they were sent to the clinic for a second one. What for?

Read more

What to do to prevent and preserve hearing in a metropolis, if I'm 21, and ringing in my ears is like a shell-shocked one?

Read more

How, from a medical point of view, can one justify the emergence of tremendous power in extreme situations?

Read more

How to prevent the suicide of a loved one? Expresses suicidal thoughts every night. Help!?

Read more

Angelina Jolie Reveals Preventative Surgery

What are the methods of preventing osteochondrosis?

Read more

Are different diets like the Scandinavian one suitable for the inhabitants of the central strip?

Read more

How to prevent loss of vision in case of average myopia (I have -3.50 and -3.75) without surgery? Maybe some exercises, procedures?

Read more

How not to get herpes? What are the means for prevention (I know that they are of different types, I am interested in prevention from any)?

Read more

Does the end justify the means? Justify your answer, give examples.?

Read more

How effective is the surgery Angelina Jolie had to avoid ovarian cancer?

What are the symptoms of glaucoma? Are there any effective methods for preventing glaucoma?

Read more

How can you justify yourself to a person who doesn't drink at all, and at the same time not seem like a bore / puritanical?

Read more

What are the consequences of opening the skull (for example after brain surgery)?

Read more

Why are expensive surgeries for children paid for by charity and not by the state?

Read more

Normaven was advised to me for the prevention of varicose veins, I would like to hear live responses.?

Read more

Angelina Jolie Details Ovarian Surgery

Where are genitals taken for sex reassignment surgery?

Read more

Should you take antiviral medications to prevent colds? If so, what are the best ones to drink in order to get sick as rarely as possible in the fall?

Read more